63. The land inhabited by the people of Lot, which lies between Iraq and
Palestine, is known as Trans-Jordan. According to the Bible, its capital town
was Sodom, which is situated either somewhere near the Dead Sea, or presently
lies submerged under it.. Apart from Sodom, according to the Talmud, there were
four other majour cities, and the land lying between these cities was dotted
with such greenery and orchards that the whole area looked like one big garden
enchanting any onlooker. However, the whole nation was destroyed and today wc
can find no trace of it. So much so that it is difficult to even locate the
main cities which they inhabited. If anything remains as a reminder of this
nation it is the Dead Sea which is also called the Sea of Lot. The Prophet Lot
who was a nephew of the Prophet Abraham, accompanied his uncle as he moved away
from Iraq. Lot sojourned to Syria, Palestincand Egypt forawhile and gained practical
experience of preaching his message. Later God bettowed prophethood upon him
and assigned to him the mission of reforming his misguided people. The people
of Sodom have been referred to as the people of Lot presumably because Lot may
have established matrimonial ties with those people.
One of the many accusations recorded gainst Lot in the Bible - and the Bible
has been tampered with extensively by the Jews - is that Lot migrated to Sodom
after an argument with Abraham (Genesis 13: 10-12).
The Qur'an refutes this baseless charge and affirms that Lot was designated
by God to work as His Messenger among his people.
The author refers to an argument between Abraham and Lot which he considers
to be a fabrication of Jews.The obvious basis of this is that such an argument
between the Prophets is inconceivable since it is unbecoming of them as Prophets.
The basis of this inference is a statement in Genesis 13:1-12.
It seems that there has been some confusion with regard to this inference. The
verses of Genesis in question make no reference to any strife between the two
Prophets. The strife to which it refers allegedly took place between the two
Prophets. In addition, when the two Prophets parted company it was on a pleasant
note for Abraham had suggested that since there was an abundance of land, Lot
should choose that part of the land he preffered so as to exclude all possibilities
of strife between their herdsmen. (See Genesis 13:1-5-Ed.)
64. The Qur'an refers elsewhere to the many evil deeds of the people of Lot.
Here the Qur'an confines itself to mentioning that most ignominious of crimes
which invited God's scourge upon them.
The hideous act of sodomy, for which the people of Lot earned notoriety, has
no doubt been committed by perverts in all times. The Greeks philosophers had
the distinction of glorifying it as a moral virtue. It was left, however, for
the modern West to vigorously propagate sodomy so much so that it was declared
legal by the legislatures of a few countries. All this has been done in the
face of the obvious fact that this form of sexual intercourse is patently unnatural.
God created distinctions between the sexes of all living beings for the purposes
of reproduction and perpetuation of the species. As far as the human species
is concerned, their creation into two sexes is related to another end as well:
that the two should come together in order to bring into existence the family
and establish human civilization. In view of this, not only were human beings
divided into two sexes, but each sex was made attractive to the other. The physical
structure and psychological make-up of each sex was shaped in keeping with the
purpose of forging bonds of mutual cordiality between the members of the two
sexes. The sexual act, which is intensely pleasurable is at once a factor leading
to the fulfilment of nature's purposes as underlined by the sexual division
of humankind as well as a reward for fulfilling these purposes.
Now, the crime of the person who commits sodomy in flagrant opposition to this
scheme of things, is not limited to that act alone. In fact he commits along
with it a number of other crimes. First, he wages war against his own nature,
against his inherent psychological predilection. This causes a major disorder
which leads to highly negative effects on the lives of both the parties involved
in that unnatural act - effects which are physical, psychological as well as
moral. Second, he acts dishonestly with nature since while he derives sexual
pleasure he fails to fulfil the societal obligation of which this pleasure is
a recompense. Third, such a person also acts dishonestly with human society.
For, although he avails himself of the advantages offered by various social
institutions, when he has an opportunity to act, he uses his abilities in a
manner which not only fails to serve that society but which positively harms
it. Apart from neglecting the abligations he owes to society, he renders himself
incapable of serving the human race and his own family. He also produces effeminacy
in at least one male and potentially pushes at least two females towards sexual
corruption and moral depravity.
65. It is evident from the present verse that the people of Lot Were not
only shameless and corrupt, but were also a people who had sunk in moral depravity
to such a degree that even the presence of a few righteous persons had become
intolerable to them. Their moral degradation left them with no patience for
anyone who sought to bring about any moral reform. Even the slightest element
of purity found in their society was too much for them, and they simply wished
to have their society purged of it.
When these people reached such a low point of wickedness and hostility to good,
God decreed that they be wiped out altogether. When the collective life of a
people becomes totally bereft of goodness and purity, it forfeits the right
to exist on earth. Their example is like that of a basket of fruit. As long
as some fruit remains firm, there is some justification to keep that basket.
But the basket has to be thrown away when the fruit becomes rotten.
66. As the Qur'an mentions elsewhere, Lot's wife supported her disbelieving
relatives to the last. Hence, when God directed Lot and his followers to migrate
from that corrupt land, He ordained that Lot's wife be left behind.
This seems to be an inference from( al- Tahrim 66: 10 - Ed).
67. The 'rainfall' in the verse does not refer to the descent of water from the sky. It refers rather to the volley of stones. The Qur'an itself mentions that their habitations were turned upside down and ruined. See (verse 85); also (Hud 11:82-3); (al-Hijr 15:74-E.)
68. In light of this verse and other references in the Qur'an, sodomy is
established as one of the deadliest sins; and that it incurred God's scourge
on those who indulged in it. We also know from the teachings of the Prophet
(peace be on him) that the Islamic state should purge society of this crime
and severely punish those guilty of it. There are several traditions from the
Prophet (peace be on him) which mention that very severe punishments were inflicted
on both partners of this act. According to one tradition, the Prophet (peace
be on him) ordered that both partners be put to death. (See Ibn Majah, Kitab
al-Hudud, 'Bab man 'amila 'Amal Qawm ut'- Ed.) In another tradition it has been
added that the culprits should be put to death whether they are married or un-married.
(Ibn Majah, Kitab al-Hudad - Ed.) In another tradition it has been said that
both parties should be stoned (to death). (Ibn Majah, Kitab al-Hudad, 'Bab man
'amila 'Amal Qawm Lut ' - Ed.) However, since no case of sodomy was reported
in the lifetime of the Prophet (peace be on him), the punishment did not acquire
a very clear and definitive shape. Among the Companions, 'Ali is of the view
that such sinners should be beheaded and instead of being buried should be cremated.
Abu Bakr also held the same view. However, 'Urnar and 'Uthman suggest that the
sinners be made to stand under the roof of a dilapidated building, which should
then be pulled down upon them. Ibn 'Abbas holds the view that those guilty of
such a sinful act should be thrown from the top of the tallest building of the
habitation and then pelted with stones. (See al-Fiqh 'ala al-Madhahib al-Arba'ah,
vol. 5, pp. 141-2 - Ed.) As for the jurists, Shafi pronounces the punishment
of death on both partners to sodomy irrespective of their marital status, and
of their role whether it be active or passive. According to Sha'bi, Zuhri, Malik
and Ahmad b. Hanbal, they should be stoned to death. Sa'id b. al-Musayyib, 'Ata',
Hasan Basri, Ibrahim Nakha'i, Sufyan Thawri and Awa'i believe that such sinners
deserve the same punishment as laid down for unlawful sexual-intercourse: that
unmarried ones should be lashed a hundred times and exiled, and that married
ones should be stoned to death. Abu Hanifah, however, does not recommend any
specific punishment. For him, the sinner should be awarded, depending on the
circumstances of each case, some deterrent punishment. According to one of the
reports, the same was the view of Shafi'i. (See Ibn Qudamah, al-Mughni, vol.
8, pp. 187-8 - Ed.)
It should also be made clear that it is altogether unlawful for the husband
to perpetrate this act on his wife. The Prophet (peace be on him), according
to a tradition in Abu Da'ud, said: 'Cursed be he who commits this act with a
woman.' (Abu Da'ud, Kitab al-Nikah, 'Bab fi Jami ' al Nikah' - Ed.) In other
collections of Hadith such as Sunan of Ibn Majah and Musnad of Ahmad b. Hanbal.
we find the following saying of the Prophet (peace be on him): 'God will not
even look at him who commits this act of sodomy with his wife in her rectum.'
(Ibn Majah, Kitab al-Nikah', 'Bab al-Nahy'an Ityan al-Nisa' fi Adbarihinn',
Ahmad b. Hanbal, Musnad, vol. 2, p. 344 - Ed.) Likewise the following saying
of the Prophet (peace be on him) is mentioned in Tirmidhi: 'He who makes sexual
intercourse with a menstruating woman, or indulges in sodomy with a woman. or
calls on a soothsayer, believing him to be true, denies the faith sent down
to Muhammad (peace be on him).' (Ibn Majah, Kitab al-Taharah, 'Bab al-Nahy 'an
ityan al-Ha'id'- Ed.)